Blog

Comparison of Advantages and Disadvantages of Electric Vehicle Power Battery Modules

Dec 15, 2025 Leave a message

 

PACK systems generally provide customized solutions based on the needs of different vehicle models: several individual battery cells are connected in series and parallel to form module units, and then through reasonable layout, the module units, PACK structural components, high and low voltage acquisition harnesses, battery management system, etc., are assembled into a PACK system.

 

EV battery pack assembly

 

I. Composition of Different Single-Cell Modules

 

Soft-pack Module
Generally composed of soft-pack battery cells, casing, end plates, terminal brackets, foam, sampling wire components, insulation protection plates, and other main components.

 

Square-shell Module
Generally composed of square aluminum-shell battery cells, side plates, end plates, top cover plates, busbars, sampling harness components, insulation film, and other main components.

 

Cylindrical Module
Generally composed of 18650/21700 and other specifications of cylindrical steel-shell battery cells, upper and lower brackets, busbars, sampling harness components, insulation plates, and other main components.

 

 

II. Comparison of Performance Advantages and Disadvantages of Different Structure Modules

 

Item Pouch Cell Module Prismatic Cell Module Cylindrical Cell Module
Packing Efficiency Pouch-type plastic square structure facilitates integration; relatively high module integration efficiency Good Shell uses high-strength steel or aluminum alloy; single cell energy density lower than pouch cells, but high mechanical strength and square structure favor integration; relatively high module integration Good Limited by the cylindrical geometry; space must be reserved for thermal management and safety, leading to low module integration efficiency. Average
Energy Density High energy density for same material system; high integration efficiency and space utilization lead to high energy density Best Relatively high energy density for same material system; high integration efficiency and space utilization lead to high energy density Good Low integration efficiency and poor space utilization result in less-than-ideal energy density. Average
High-rate Charge/Discharge Capability Strong heat dissipation and current conduction enable high-power fast charging/discharging Good Strong heat dissipation and current conduction enable high-power fast charging/discharging Best The cylindrical structure has poor current conduction and heat dissipation, making it unsuitable for high-power fast charging/discharging. Average
Life & Reliability Good heat dissipation and current conduction; pouch structure requires mechanical fixation; cells can be connected by laser or ultrasonic welding Best Good heat dissipation and current conduction; steel/aluminum shell provides high mechanical strength; laser sealing welding process ensures high life and reliability Good Poor heat dissipation/current conduction, along with numerous connection and welding points, lead to average module lifespan and reliability. Average
Cost Pouch structure requires mechanical fixation, adding extra cost Good High integration efficiency, good mechanical performance, easy thermal management; thus lowest cost Best Due to the high number of individual cells, extra costs are incurred to ensure temperature uniformity and module safety. Good
Key/Special Processes Pressure-sensitive adhesive spraying, thermal conductive adhesive coating, module stacking and compression, module housing insertion, welding   Adhesive coating, module stacking and compression, plasma cleaning, welding   Ultrasonic wire bonding (aluminum wire), adhesive coating, liquid cooling  
Advantages High packing efficiency, high energy density, good safety, good cycle performance, high lightweight potential   High packing efficiency, relatively high energy density, high integration efficiency, low cost   High integration flexibility, unified product models, mature process technology  
Disadvantages Complex process, high equipment requirements, relatively high cost   Single cell energy density lower than pouch cells; poor thermal runaway safety   limited capacity improvement potential, low energy density, complex management methods  

 

 

About us

 

Acey Intelligent specializes in providing one-stop solutions for semi-automatic/fully-automatic assembly lines of lithium battery packs used in ESS, UAV, E-Bike, E-Scooter, Power Tools, Two/Three Wheelers, Etc. In Addition, we provide a complete set of battery pack assembly equipment, such as Cell Grading Machine, Battery Sorting Machine, Insulation Paper Sticking Machine, CCD tester, Manual/Automatic Spot Welding Machine, BMS Tester, Battery Comprehensive Tester and Battery Pack Test System, etc.

 

battery pack assembly line

 

 

Contact now

 

 

Send Inquiry